Thousands of car buyers who financed their vehicles may soon be eligible for compensation worth billions of pounds following a pivotal Court of Appeal decision. This case involves hidden commissions paid by finance companies to dealerships without customers’ knowledge, raising widespread industry implications.
Marcus Johnson, a 34-year-old from Cwmbran, Wales, was one of the plaintiffs in this landmark ruling. In 2017, Johnson financed a Suzuki Swift through Trade Centre Wales. Unbeknownst to him, the dealership received a hefty 25% commission—amounting to £1,650—which was folded into his loan payments. Johnson only learned about the commission later and was “furious,” describing the added costs as “heart-breaking.”
The Court of Appeal’s October ruling determined that the finance company must refund the hidden commission, plus interest, to Johnson. This decision entitles him to just over £3,200. This ruling has set a precedent, potentially opening the door for numerous car finance customers to pursue similar claims, as many were likely unaware of similar undisclosed commissions added to their loans.
Billions Could Be Set Aside by Car Finance Companies
Following the decision, many car finance firms are now reserving substantial funds to settle future claims. Lloyds Bank, for instance, has already earmarked £450 million for potential compensation related to similar cases. This trend reflects the likelihood that other affected motorists could receive substantial reimbursements as more cases emerge.
Johnson financed his vehicle for £4,600 through MotoNovo Finance, a Cardiff-based firm arranged by Trade Centre Wales. Despite making payments for three years, he still owed £3,500 by 2020, which he assumed was due to loan interest. He later discovered that the hidden commission significantly inflated his payments, leading him to sell the vehicle.
HD Law attorney Kevin Durkin, who represented Johnson, explained that the dealership’s commission arrangement was vaguely referenced in the fine print—a disclosure deemed insufficient by the court. “The commission was buried in the paperwork,” Durkin said, adding that this practice was widespread across the industry.
Changes to Car Finance Regulations
Since 2021, new regulations by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) ban discretionary commission arrangements in car financing, improving transparency for consumers. However, before this rule change, dealerships had no explicit obligation to disclose these fees.
This case revealed that a lack of clarity around commissions has long been an issue. According to Durkin, nearly every client he has represented in similar cases has unknowingly paid commissions. The Court of Appeal clarified that hiding such details in the fine print does not meet disclosure standards, as borrowers are unlikely to examine every detail closely.
A New Avenue for Affected Car Buyers
As this ruling gains attention, consumers who purchased cars on finance may now seek compensation, potentially leading to billions in payouts. Johnson, who now says he will avoid financing vehicles altogether, expressed relief at the court’s decision. “It was a big moment of relief, excitement, and happiness all at the same time,” he said, hopeful that others could reclaim hidden costs.
This decision offers a beacon of hope for countless car buyers unknowingly charged extra through undisclosed commissions. Johnson, motivated by the prospect of helping other families, remarked, “To me, that’s worth more than the money I reclaimed.”
As the car finance sector adjusts to this new precedent, the case is expected to impact dealership practices significantly, ensuring greater transparency and fairness for consumers in the future.
Read more:
